Starving Council Housing of funds

Leave a comment

Time to re-address the Council housing ‘debt settlement’

In April 2012 a new Council Housing finance system, ‘self-financing’, was introduced. The system had been designed by the New Labour government but was introduced by the coalition government. Housing Minister Grant Shapps said that the new system would “give Councils the resources they need to manage their own housing stock for the longer term – correcting decades of under-funding”. In fact under-funding was not corrected but built into the new system (see Appendix). Councils did have more money than they had under the previous system because what was known as a ‘negative subsidy’ was ended. In 2005 the Audit Commission reported that 82% of local authorities were subject to ‘negative subsidy’, meaning they received no subsidy and had to make a payment to central government from their rent income. According to the Audit Commission this comprised some £630 million a year. Whilst some of this was redistributed to other Councils, in the four years from 2008 tenants’ rents subsidised the Treasury to the tune of almost £1.5 billion1. It was predicted that if the old system, the ‘housing subsidy system’, continued, then eventually all local authorities would suffer from ‘negative subsidy’, largely as a result of year on year rent increases above the level of inflation. (Read on below or download a PDF here starvingchoffunds) More

Rent cut: compensate Councils for the losss of income

Leave a comment

First the good news. The government is proposing to cut Council (and Housing Association) rents by 1% a year for 4 years starting in 2016. Tenants will welcome the proposal, especially after many years of above inflation increases. However, the motivation of the government is certainly not the interests of tenants. It will save on its housing benefit bill an estimated £1.445 billion by 2020/21. Moreover, tenants will be adversely affected because the loss of rental income to the Councils will mean that they will have to cut their expenditure on the upkeep and maintenance of our homes. To understand why this is the case we have to look at the new Council housing finance system which was introduced in 2012, so-called ‘self-financing’. (Download a PDF of this article here to read offline rentcut or read on below) More

Crisis of affordability in Swindon as house price rise outstrips earnings

Leave a comment

The latest ONS (Office of National Statistics) statistics for house prices in local authority areas show the median (middle point) house price for Swindon in 2014  surpassed the highest previous level reached in 2007 before the housing crash. It was £165,000 compared to its post-crash low of £147,000. Detached dwellings now have a median price of £250,000, semi-detached homes £181,000, terraced houses £142,000.[1] The only exception, not having nearly reached or surpassed the previous highs, are maisonettes and flats. They were at £109,500 in 2014, still well below their 2007 high point of £138,000. This may well reflect the change in the composition of new build with a higher percentage of flats built than previously.

When the crash came in 2007/8 there was a precipitous decline in sales. In Swindon in 2007 there were 6,506 domestic property sales, nearly 8% of properties in the town. In 2008 it fell to 3,113. For the next 4 years sales remained below 3,000 a year. By 2014 they had risen to 4,010, or just 4.3% of properties in the expanding town. More

‘Right to Buy’ sales: the government’s ‘one for one replacement’ scam

Leave a comment

Brandon Lewis, the latest in a long list of short-lived housing ministers since 2010 has issued a press release on ‘right to buy’ sales. It is a classic example of using statistics to obscure the real situation. Mr Lewis, as with the previous housing ministers under the coalition government has a problem. The coalition spoke of ‘one for one’ replacement of homes sold under their new version of RTB with increased discounts. However, as we shall see, this did not mean replacement of all homes sold, as the term would seem to imply. Since the scheme was introduced in April 2012 there has been a significant gap between the numbers sold and the numbers replaced.

Like any dishonest propagandist you have to weigh Lewis’s words carefully. Take these.

“Today’s figures (25 June 1015) also show that 3,337 new starts and acquisitions have been made since the scheme was reinvigorated in 2012. This means that the additional homes sold in the first year of the scheme are already being replaced on a one for one basis nationally.” More

Housing ‘choice’… for those who can afford it

Leave a comment

Swindon Council’s Conservative Group says it will support the extension of ‘right to buy’ but fails to justify the policy nor explain how it will improve the housing situation.

Swindon Tenants Campaign Group recently wrote to Swindon Councillors calling on them to oppose the extension of ‘right to buy’ (RTB) to Housing Associations and the enforced sale of ‘high value’ Council housing to pay for it.[1] The receipts from the sale of Council homes would be used to subsidise Housing Associations for part of or all of the difference between the discount to their tenants under RTB and the value of their homes.

We have received a reply from Emma Faramarzi on behalf of the Conservative Group (See below). The essential message was that they had won the election and this policy “received the necessary endorsement by the British electorate” so the group would be supporting the government. Of course, 63.1% of those who voted voted against them, and they secured just under 25% support from the electorate. (Download a PDF of this here faramarzi or read on below)  More

Only one in nine Council ‘right to buy’ sales replaced

Leave a comment

The latest statistical release from the Department of Communities & Local Government for England shows that 12,304 homes were sold under ‘right to buy’, making 29,909 since the government introduced its increased discounts.  This doesn’t include sale of Housing Association homes, of which nearly 7,000 were sold in the first two years from April 2012.

Replacements of homes sold, either new build or acquisitions (i.e. buying already existing properties on the market, commonly ex-Council homes), were only only 3,337 (See Note below) since 2012 or around one in nine of those sold.

Between 2010 and 2014 the number of Council homes fell from 1,785,845 to 1,669,000, a decline of 116,845.

In Swindon in the last 3 years 164 Council homes have been sold under ‘right to buy’.


‘Starts on site’ include preparation of site but not necessarily a start on building the property



“Right To Buy 2” – throw out the Bill


It’s doubtful that the Tories imagined that they would have to implement the extension of “right to buy’ to Housing Associations given that they did not expect to win a majority. If they had been in a coalition with the Liberal Democrats again they would have been unable to push through the proposal given Libdem opposition to it. Perhaps this explains the lack of detail available. They don’t appear to have thought it through, even by the lamentable standards of their housing policy. (Download a PDF here rtb2 or read on below) More

Older Entries


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 175 other followers

%d bloggers like this: